Cazenovia Homes for Sale

Cazenovia Homes for Sale

Welcome to Cazenovia, New York – a picturesque gem nestled in the heart of Madison County. Known for its stunning natural beauty and rich history, Cazenovia offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. With its serene lakes, lush landscapes, and vibrant community, it's no wonder that this idyllic town has become a sought-after destination for homebuyers.

Cazenovia boasts a delightful downtown area filled with quaint shops, local eateries, and cultural attractions. Stroll along the charming streets and soak in the atmosphere, or enjoy a leisurely afternoon at Cazenovia Lake, where you can partake in a variety of outdoor activities, from boating to fishing. The town is also home to beautiful parks and trails, perfect for hiking and enjoying the stunning views year-round.

For those considering a move to this enchanting town, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse lifestyles and preferences. Whether you’re dreaming of a cozy cottage, a spacious family home, or a modern townhouse, Cazenovia has something for everyone. The real estate market here reflects the area’s charm, offering properties that seamlessly blend comfort and style, often with breathtaking views of the surrounding landscape.

Cazenovia is not just a place to live; it’s a community where neighbors become friends, and every day feels like a retreat. If you’re ready to discover your dream home in this enchanting town, explore the available listings today and take the first step towards embracing the Cazenovia lifestyle!

Newest Cazenovia Homes for Sale

$449,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1701820 MLS
Welcome to 102 Emick Lane, a beautifully maintained ranch in the desirable Greenleaf Station neighborhood, originally built as the community’s model home with quality craftsmanship, thoughtful design, and upscale finishes throughout. Offering effortless one-level living with an expansive lower level ready for entertaining or additional living space, this home has been meticulously cared for and thoughtfully improved year after year. The original model home featured an open floor plan, abundant natural light, hardwood floors, a spacious primary suite, first-floor laundry, and a beautifully appointed kitchen overlooking the main living areas. Since 2020, the owners have invested extensively in both the home and property. The lower level has been enhanced with commercial-grade luxury vinyl plank flooring, recessed lighting, and adjustable storage shelving. The basement is ready to be finished off and offers rough in plumbing ready for a full bathroom addition. Outdoor living has been transformed with stunning landscaped perennial gardens, lilacs, Norwegian spruces, pollinator gardens, a front patio, backyard fire pit gathering area, solar landscape lighting, creating exceptional curb appeal in every season. Additional updates include a 10’ x 14’ Amish-built storage shed, whole-house 14 kW Kohler standby generator, and so much more. One of Greenleaf Station’s greatest features is its walkability. Sidewalk-lined streets make it an easy stroll into the heart of the historic Village of Cazenovia, where you’ll enjoy boutique shopping, locally owned restaurants, coffee shops, farmers markets, community events, and the timeless character that makes this one of Central New York’s most beloved communities. Outdoor enthusiasts will love being just minutes from Cazenovia Lake, where you can enjoy boating, kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing, swimming, and breathtaking sunsets. Nearby year-round walking and nature trails offer miles of scenic hiking, birdwatching, cross-country skiing, and snowshoeing, making it easy to enjoy every season right outside your door. This home offers it all and is ready for you to call it home!

102 Emick Lane, Cazenovia
$525,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1701862 MLS
Location and setting are the two things buyers can never change, and this exceptional property offers both. Built in 2000, this beautifully maintained Colonial is ideally situated on 1.23 acres adjacent to the 11th green of the Cazenovia Country Club, surrounded by picturesque horse farms, white fencing, and rolling countryside, yet just minutes south of the Village of Cazenovia. Offering 2,488 square feet of living space, the home features 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, gleaming hardwood floors, central air conditioning, and a flowing open floor plan designed for comfortable everyday living and entertaining. The spacious family room offers custom built-ins and a cozy gas fireplace, complemented by a formal dining room and an additional living room, providing flexible space for gatherings, holidays, or a quiet retreat. A full basement offers excellent storage or the opportunity to create additional finished living space. Step outside to the expansive rear deck overlooking a fabulous backyard—an ideal setting for entertaining, family gatherings, or simply relaxing while taking in the peaceful views. As an added bonus, the sellers are offering a $5,000 carpet credit to the buyer at closing, providing the opportunity to personalize the flooring to your own taste. This is a rare opportunity to own a home where the setting is every bit as impressive as the home itself.

2313 Ballina Road, Cazenovia
$499,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1698828 MLS
Whether it is because of the convenient "walking distance" location within the Village of Cazenovia, or the desired cul-de-sac, Gillette Lane has and will always be a sought after neighborhood. An easy walk to the shops, lake, Farmer's Market, expansive link trail, fireworks on the 4th or annual tree lighting, you will love being close to all this great community offers while reveling in the many attributes of 12 Gillette Lane. Well maintained with substantial improvements during their 6 year tenure at this house, it is truly move-in ready. Inside, the first floor features an updated kitchen, sun room, living room, dining room and family room as well as a half bath. Both the wood burning fireplace and gas stove will beckon you on a chilly afternoon or a wonderful Central New York snowfall. They are an ideal destination to sit and reflect, read a really intriguing book or to take a deserved nap. The beautiful deck is steps away which overlooks the spacious in-ground salt water filtered pool and an abundance of privacy behind that. Upstairs you'll find 3 of the 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, one of which is in the primary bedroom. The lower level is partially finished with a code-compliant bedroom and full bath. There are many options for the use of this space, which walks out to the pool area under the deck. The exterior of the home is dominated by the spacious rear deck and pool. In the front is a smaller deck at the front door which begs for a few comfy chairs to enjoy your coffee and the sunrise. The driveway is spacious for visiting friends or family. This is a wonderful listing and is appropriately priced to reflect the condition and environs.

12 Gillette Lane, Cazenovia
$99,000
5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1699376 MLS
Charming small-town setting meets flexible multi-generational living in this New Woodstock property with a full in-law suite. This spacious residence offers the main living quarters plus a private in-law suite — ideal for extended family, guests, or a home office/studio setup. Both the main area and the suite are ready for a full cosmetic and mechanical update, giving you the chance to customize every detail to your taste while building instant equity along the way. Tucked into the quiet hamlet of New Woodstock, you're just a short drive from Cazenovia and the greater Syracuse area, so you get small-town peace without sacrificing convenience. Great bones, endless potential — bring your contractor and your vision.

2627 Mill Street, Cazenovia
$1,650,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1698874 MLS
Welcome to 2970 West Lake Rd., one of the most distinctive and enchanting estates on Cazenovia Lake. This timeless Georgian Colonial delivers the best of both worlds: six impeccably manicured acres creating a serene, private sanctuary you’ll never want to leave, paired with breathtaking lakefront living that feels like a dream come true. For buyers dreaming of the lake lifestyle or those who never imagined they would own a lake house, this is your opportunity to live it with style. Built in 1975 and cherished with uncompromising care, this 4,200-square-foot home blends elegant architecture with effortless comfort. Five bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms provide generous space, while the first-floor office, with closet and a fireplace easily becomes a sixth bedroom for family or guests. Inside, sunlight pours across rich hardwood floors, highlighting the warm, inviting living spaces. The kitchen steals the show with its expansive workspace, seamless design, and show-stopping live-edge black walnut island - the ultimate hub for unforgettable gatherings! Adjacent, the family room features dramatic custom mahogany walls, views of the lake, and a crackling wood-burning fireplace. A sun-drenched sunroom offers sweeping views of the park-like grounds, complete with a chipping green, and the sparkling lake beyond. Downstairs, the finished walkout lower level is pure entertainment magic: a cozy movie lounge, a custom speakeasy-style sports bar, flexible workshop/hobby space, and an additional room perfect for a home gym or second office. Outside, approximately 90 feet of pristine lake frontage awaits, anchored by a charming seasonal cottage with loft, comfortable entertaining area, and a covered porch framed by exceptional water views. The property includes three separate tax parcels, highlighted by a rare 2-acre buildable lot for future dreams. Privacy, timeless character, flawless condition, and true lakefront luxury, this is lakeside living reimagined. Don’t just visit 2970 West Lake Rd. Come claim the life you’ve always wanted.

2970 W Lake Road, Cazenovia
$359,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ S1697798 MLS
A classic 4 bedroom, 2.1 bath center Colonial located north of the Village of Cazenovia on a wonderful, desirous cul-de-sac. The layout is ageless, with copious natural light and excellent flow. Recent, substantive improvements include the kitchen and rear deck. The sun room on the southwest corner of the house provides abundant year-round sunlight which is a welcome refuge when winter grows a bit tiresome. Upstairs are the 4 bedrooms and 2 full baths, one of which is in the primary bedroom. The lower level is partially finished, perfect for play, hobbies or a work space. The lawn area outside is generous and has served well as a recreational area for the budding soccer star and spot to relax. This is priced to reflect the "dings and dents" that come with a well loved home. One of just a few houses available under $375,000 in the Cazenovia area. The sellers love the home but need more space with a growing family.

5481 Oxbow Road, Cazenovia
$329,900
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1675067 MLS
Welcome to this charming Village of Cazenovia home, ideally situated on one of the community's most desirable tree-lined streets. Rich in character and thoughtfully updated, this 4-bedroom, 1.5-bath home features beautiful hardwood floors, a welcoming living room with a gas fireplace, and an eat-in kitchen with direct access to a spacious deck overlooking the private backyard. A versatile bonus room upstairs offers the perfect space for a home office, guest room, or future expansion. Convenient first-floor laundry, a detached garage, and plenty of outdoor space for gardening, entertaining, or play add to the home's appeal. Just a short stroll to the Village's shops, restaurants, parks, and award-winning Cazenovia schools, this home offers the perfect blend of historic charm, modern comfort, and an unbeatable location.

40 Sullivan Street, Cazenovia
$849,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1696673 MLS
Enjoy the rare combination of country privacy, sweeping NW views of the Pompey Hills & valley, AND ownership of a nearby lakefront parcel w/rare access to Cazenovia Lake & views toward the village shoreline. Set on 7.33 acres along one of Cazenovia's most coveted cul-de-sac roads, this Contemporary home is just 1.8 miles from the village, offering easy access to shops, restaurants, schools, Fayetteville (20 min.) and SYR hospitals/airport (30 min.). As you approach the home, the panoramic views immediately command your attention. Recent improvements include a new roof, boiler, mini-splits for cooling, and all-new Pella windows and exterior doors. Inside, walls of glass frame the views & fill the home with natural light. A floor to ceiling stone fireplace anchors the great room, where oak floors, custom built-ins, & multiple access points to the main deck, side deck, & patio create seamless indoor/outdoor living. The updated kitchen opens to the dining/family combo areas & features granite countertops, modern oak cabinetry, & Wolf & Bosch appliances. Just off the foyer are a powder room and office/playroom with built-in shelving. Adjacent to the kitchen is a thoughtfully designed work zone with laundry, a 2nd powder room, extensive cabinetry, drawers, counter space, and direct access to the screened porch, bluestone patio, and oversized mudroom leading to the attached 3-bay garage. The private primary suite occupies its own level with a Juliet balcony, adjoining office/nursery, spacious bath, & oversized walk-in dressing room w/custom built-ins. A few steps below the main level are the guest/family BRs and full bath. The walk-out LL is a fully finished living space, with abundant storage, and is partially plumbed for a future bath. INCLUDED is a rare 203' (.33-acre) lakefront parcel on Cazenovia Lake. The parcel is owned as a undivided 1/2 interest w/50' easement benefiting a third party. While non-buildable, it does permit a dock—an increasingly opportunity for lake access in Cazenovia. Properties offering this combination of acreage, panoramic views, extensive updates, and Cazenovia Lake access rarely become available.

4171 Lorenzo Farm Road, Cazenovia
$875,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1697306 MLS
Feel instantly at home in this beautiful antique house only about a mile and a half south of the historic Village of Cazenovia. Set on 10.5 acres, it offers the charm of yesteryear with updates for today- especially because it has a flexible floor plan with both large spaces for entertaining and cozy spots to snuggle in. The kitchen-great room is 1000 square feet on it's own, anchored by a 6x6 butcher block island... There is also a large dining area, a butler‘s pantry, family room area with a wood-burning stove, and a first floor laundry in the kitchen wing of the house. The first floor also has a beautiful formal dining room with elegant built-ins, a rich, wood-paneled den with gas fireplace, and another room that is currently a formal living room, but it was originally a primary suite on the first floor with an attached full bath. The first floor is rounded out on the north end by a grand addition built in the 40's as a music room- even with a stage- and highlighted by beautiful natural light, windows overlooking the in-ground pool, arched ceiling, fireplace, and French doors leading to a deck and terrace overlooking the acreage... It's truly stunning! Upstairs you'll find a lovely primary suite with vaulted ceilings, walk-in closet, attached full bath, a pretty dressing room with another vanity, and a balcony overlooking the acreage. There are the two large Jack and Jill bedrooms that share a full bath. Beautiful wide-plank floors throughout! Connected through the dressing room, or accessible from a second staircase from the kitchen, is another sweet little bedroom area (not included in tax record sq ft). Other highlights- a wet bar with beverage frig- would make a great coffee bar, a fully screened porch, bluestone walkways and patio, gorgeous original woodwork and hardware, and so many closets! Out buildings consist of a garden shed, a 2-story 2-car barn/garage, and a 2-car 2-story carriage house w/workshop space attached to the big barn. This is your vintage country dream property and just a short trip to the heart of the village, shops & restaurants, Cazenovia Lake, and all the lovely trails and amenities that Cazenovia has to offer... It's a must see!

3857 East Road, Cazenovia
$2,795,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ S1694954 MLS
Invest in a classic American lake village where historic architecture, walkable streets, and a pristine freshwater lake create enduring demand from both full-time residents and second-home buyers. Cazenovia offers the four-season Upstate New York lifestyle today's buyers are seeking: boating and lakeside parks in summer, vibrant foliage and scenic country roads in autumn, and convenient access to ski areas and city amenities throughout winter and spring. With its preserved historic character, thriving village center, and thoughtful long-term stewardship, Cazenovia is an exceptional setting for a second home, relocation, or long-term investment. For New York City residents, Cazenovia presents a relaxed, less-discovered alternative to the Hudson Valley or the Hamptons. Enjoy weekends strolling Albany Street, browsing boutiques, dining at The Brewster Inn and other acclaimed local restaurants, and watching sailboats drift across the lake at sunset. It's an easy, scenic escape from the city, yet it feels a world away. Imagine waking each morning to shimmering waters, gentle breezes, and the timeless beauty of Cazenovia Lake. Positioned remarkably close to the shoreline, this extraordinary residence captures breathtaking lake views from nearly every room, creating the remarkable sensation of living aboard a private yacht. Designed for both sophisticated entertaining and relaxed everyday living, the home's inviting floor plan showcases exceptional craftsmanship, rich architectural woodwork, and timeless design. At its heart is a spectacular chef's kitchen featuring multiple cooking stations, premium commercial-grade appliances, and a fully equipped prep kitchen overlooking both the dining room and the lake. Thoughtfully designed for those who love to cook, entertain, and gather, it offers the functionality of a professional culinary workspace while remaining warm, elegant, and beautifully connected to the home's principal living spaces. More than a home, this is a place where unforgettable gatherings, cherished traditions, and lifelong memories unfold against one of Central New York's most spectacular waterfront settings.

1120 Marlyn Park Drive, Cazenovia
$899,900
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ S1693747 MLS
Welcome to one of Cazenovia Village's most treasured homes. Built in 1838, this stunning 5,400-square-foot Colonial masterfully blends timeless character with thoughtful modern updates, creating an extraordinary residence in the heart of the village. Meticulously maintained and lovingly cared for, every room reflects the elegance and craftsmanship of a bygone era while offering the comforts today's buyers desire. The gracious floor plan features beautiful formal living and music rooms, an elegant dining room perfect for entertaining, and a warm, inviting family room just off the kitchen. Sliding glass doors lead to a charming brick patio overlooking the private, partially fenced backyard—an ideal setting for outdoor dining, gardening, or relaxing. The beautifully renovated kitchen offers modern amenities while remaining true to the home's historic character including a beautiful 48-inch Wolf Range w/pot filler and quartz countertops. The luxurious primary bath has been thoughtfully updated with timeless finishes that complement the home's architectural style. A welcoming front porch provides the perfect place to enjoy village life and greet neighbors. With four spacious bedrooms, three full baths, and two half baths, there is room for family, guests, and entertaining. A first-floor office with an adjoining half bath offers excellent flexibility and could easily be converted into a first-floor bedroom for those seeking one-level living. A rare bonus is the oversized heated two-car garage featuring a loft space ideal for a private office, artist's studio, workshop, fitness room, or recreation area. Zoned for both residential and business use, this exceptional property presents endless possibilities for those looking to combine home and work in one remarkable location. Just steps from Cazenovia's charming shops, restaurants, parks, schools, and beautiful Cazenovia Lake, this is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to own a distinguished historic home that perfectly balances classic elegance, modern convenience, and unmatched versatility.

11 Albany Street, Cazenovia
$460,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ S1693701 MLS
This gorgeous, updated, versatile Village property effortlessly adapts to your lifestyle, offering a rare blend of space, comfort, and incredible flexibility. Set on a premium .4 acre lot—unusually spacious for village living—this property is a true sanctuary. Whether you host summer gatherings in the dedicated outdoor oasis, dine al fresco under the stars, or unwind in the private hot tub, the exterior space is for making memories. Inside, the warm embrace of the open-concept living and dining area is anchored by a gas fireplace complementing the dual zone hot water baseboard heat, ideal for crisp CNY winter weather. Designed with both modern convenience and longevity in mind, the flexible floor plan features a highly desirable and unique first-floor ensuite and first-floor laundry room. The second-floor bedrooms are large and bright. With abundant and ample closet space thoughtfully integrated throughout the home, everything will have its place! A detached two-car garage provides even more room for vehicles, storage for seasonal gear, or a even a workshop. The Crown Jewel: beyond the main house lies a spectacular, fully independent, true Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU). This unique and extremely rare asset offers multiple possibilities to match life's changing chapters: multigenerational living for an extended family; a private guest space providing friends with a beautiful, self-contained retreat; or passive income by utilizing the unit as a highly desirable rental offering income to offset a mortgage payment along with possible tax benefits. The ADU has one bedroom, living room, kitchen, bathroom, and separate parking. The location is amazing as well. Step out the door and immerse yourself in the very best of Cazenovia. Located less than a half-mile to the historic, vibrant downtown shops and dining, the beautiful college, and the scenic paths of the CPF Gorge Trail. This is more than just a house; it is a flexible estate tailored for a special owner looking for old world charm with updates for modern living. Take a look...you'll fall in love. Check out the floorplan, the photos, and contact your agent to make arrangments for a personal showing.

11 Corwin Street, Cazenovia
Start Your Search